Key takeaways
• Most unsuccessful award entries fail long before anyone starts writing.
• Judges don’t reward the best story; they reward the strongest evidence.
• Choosing the wrong award or category can undermine an otherwise excellent chance of success.
• A good communications partner should challenge your award strategy, not just polish your submission.
• Strong award entries are the result of months of collecting proof, not days spent writing.
“Can you make our awards entry stronger?” is a common communications agency request. Usually, it comes after disappointment.
“We’ve entered before.” “We thought we had a good chance.” “We just need someone to write it better.”
On the surface, it sounds perfectly reasonable. If the judges didn’t choose your entry, perhaps the story wasn’t told well enough. Perhaps the language wasn’t persuasive enough. Perhaps an agency can find the angle that everyone else missed.
Sometimes that’s true, but more often than businesses realise, they’re that’s not what’s going to make the biggest difference. Because an award submission isn’t a creative writing exercise; it’s a piece of evidence.
Judges can instantly spot the difference between marketing language and measurable impact
Assess your evidence before deciding on the award
Winning an award can be a huge morale boost for teams internally and amplify your reputation in the market. Hence, the decision as to which award to enter is often based on what an organisation wants to be recognised or known for, not necessarily whether it actually has the evidence the judges are looking for.
Rather than starting with the award you want to win, start by assessing what you can genuinely prove, then match the award accordingly. Perhaps you’re not ready to win Innovation of the Year, but you have an outstanding story about customer collaboration. Perhaps your sustainability journey is still developing but your apprenticeship programme is genuinely industry leading.
And that’s okay. The goal isn’t to find the most prestigious award; it’s to find one where your achievements already speak for themselves.
Gathering evidence is harder than writing the entry
Good writing matters. It’s important to make complex technologies easier to understand for judging panels who may not be familiar with your particular products and terminology and give them the context to understand why your industry contribution is so significant. We can simplify language, add explanations, improve the structure, remove repetition, and strengthen the overall narrative. However, we can’t come up with the data, real-world examples, and stakeholder testimonials ourselves, which are the most decisive factors.
In fact, clients are often surprised how little of an award entry they can actually outsource to an agency. The proof has to come from the organisation itself. We can advise on the type of evidence that we believe will best support the claims made in the submission and will push back if we believe it needs to be more specific, more detailed, or more recent. However, most of the time and effort in the entry goes into the information gathering and that’s often a lot of work that the client needs to do by themselves.
Evidence should be gathered year-round, not right before the deadline
Often, the challenge isn’t that the right evidence doesn’t exist, but that there isn’t enough time to gather it from different parts of the organisation or even external third parties before the award needs to be submitted. Or it might be that great evidence isn’t shared with the marketing or communications team because it has been overlooked as a normal part of how the company does business. This could be three days saved on a customer project, an engineer solving a problem that no competitor could, or a safety improvement to a common process.
Evidence like this has a habit of disappearing if nobody captures it, so the aim should be to keep an ongoing record throughout the year. It might just be the missing puzzle piece for a successful awards entry but could equally be as valuable as a proof point in a thought leadership article, white paper, conference presentation, or social media post.
Sometimes the best advice is: don’t enter
Hannah Kitchener
Associate Director
About the author
Hannah is an associate director in the UK, leading strategic campaigns for industrial clients across the EMEA region. A professionally qualified journalist (NCTJ), she combines specialist sectoral knowledge in construction, energy, and materials handling with a strong network of trade media contacts to secure valuable coverage. Her expertise in inter-cultural communication, honed by degrees in modern languages and translation, is key to executing campaigns that succeed across diverse European markets.

